Along came a spider...

8.1. The Purposes of an Award in Tort

Introductory Note

8.1.1. English Law

Introductory Note
8.E.1. House of Lords, Rookes v Barnard. dismissal resulting from intimidation of employee
8.E.2. House of Lords, Cassell & Co Ltd v Broome. defamation concerning naval disaster

8.1.2. German Law

Introductory Note
8.G.3. BGH, 6 July 1955. compensation and satisfaction
8.G.4. BGH, 4 June 1992. sexual abuse
8.G.5. BGH, 15 November 1994. Caroline of Monaco insulted

8.1.3. French Law

Introductory Note
8.F.6. Cass civ 2e, 8 May 1964, Harang-Martin v Bonneau. insulting neighbour
8.F.7. Paris, 26 April 1983, SA Cogedipresse v C. deathbed photograph

8.2. The Principle of Full Reparation

Introductory Note

8.2.1. English Law

Introductory Note
8.E.8. Court of Appeal, Darbishire v Warran. damaged shooting-brake
8.E.9. Privy Council, Selvanayagam v University of the West Indies. diabetic refusing surgery
8.E.10. Court of Appeal, Ward v James. quadriplegic plaintiff
8.E.11. Court of Appeal, Strand Electric and Engineering Co Ltd v Brisford Entertainments Ltd. wrongfully detained switchboards

8.2.2. German Law

Introductory Note
8.G.12. BGH, 15 October 1991. damaged Porsche
8.G.13. BGH, 13 May 1953. surgery or retraining
8.G.14. BGH, 8 June 1976. youngster permanently injured
8.G.15. BGH, 8 October 1971. electrical wall sockets

8.2.3. French Law

Introductory Note
8.F.16. Cass civ 2e, 4 February 1982, Babin v Cie La Union et le Phénix espagnol. car damaged by lorry
8.F.17. Cass civ 2e, 9 July 1981, Houillères du Bassin du Centre et du Midi v Chabalier. house damaged by subsidence
8.F.18. Cass crim, 3 July 1969, Pourpour v Reynaud. injured plaintiff refusing surgery
8.F.19. Cass crim, 26 June 1984, Guimber v Aaron. medical disability scale
8.F.20. Cass civ 1re, 17 November 1987, Delon v SA "Ici Paris". unauthorized publication

8.3. Form of Compensation and Assessment of Future Damage.

Introductory Note

8.3.1. English Law

Introductory Note
8.E.21. Court of Appeal, Brunsden v Humphrey. Injured coachman
8.E.22. House of Lords, Lim Poh Choo v Islington Area Health Authority. plaintiff suffering irremediable disability
8.E.23. House of Lords, Wells v Wells and Thomas v Brighton Health Authority and Page v Sheerness Steel Co Plc (conjoined appeals). serious brain damage

8.3.2. German Law

Introductory Note
8.G.24. BGH, 20 December 1960. totally invalidated 25 years later
8.G.25. BGH, 8 January 1981. Beetle and Porsche collide

8.3.3. French Law

Introductory Note
8.F.26. Cass civ 2e, 29 April 1994, Groupement français d'assurances v Marcellus. periodical payments award
8.F.27. Cass Ch Mixte, 6 November 1974, Sourdonnier v Gallien. disabled mason
8.F.28. Cass Req, 30 December 1946, Établissements Brun d'Arre v Menard. plaintiff improving after judgment (1)
8.F.29. Cass civ 2e, 12 October 1972, Deletang v Préfet d''Ille-et-Vilaine et Adam. plaintiff improving after judgment (2)

8.4. Loss of or Damage to Property

@ 8.4.1. German Law (Additional Materials)

Introductory Note
8.G.30. BGH, 23 March 1976. unrepaired car sold
8.G.31. BGH, 24 March 1959. new for old
8.G.32. BGH, 9 July 1986. use of house prohibited by city council

@ 8.4.2. English Law (Additional Materials)

Introductory Note
8.E.33. Court of Appeal, Dominion Mosaics and Tile Co v Trafalgar Trucking Co. paternoster machines
8.E.34. Court of Appeal, The London Corporation. unrepaired ship sold
8.E.35. Court of Appeal, Harbutt's 'Plasticine' Ltd v Wayne Tank and Pump Co Ltd. plasticine factory destroyed by fire
8.E.36. House of Lords, The Mediana. standby lightship

@ 8.4.3. French Law (Additional Materials)

Introductory Note
8.F.37. Cass crim, 17 December 1969, Amey. damaged car (1)
8.F.38. Cass civ 2e, 31 March 1993, Thévenin v Les Cars bleus Brossard. damaged car (2)
8.F.39. Cass civ 2e, 9 May 1972, Société Bonneau v Ponce. collapse of wall
8.F.40. Cass civ 2e, 23 November 1988, SMAC Acieroïd v Perrot. buildings irreparably damaged by mining
8.F.41. Cass crim,6 December 1983, SNCF v Hubert. damaged turbo-train

8.5. Compensation: Personal Injury and Death

@ 8.5.1. German Law (Additional Materials)

Introductory Note
8.G.42. BGH, 5 May 1970. qualified chemist
8.G.43. BGH, 16 February 1970. remarriage of widower

@ 8.5.2. French Law (Additional Materials)

Introductory Note
8.F.44. Cass civ 2e, 3 June 1955, Établ Cabour v Lecat. injured employee
8.F.45. Cass crim, 7 July 1966, Desombres v Pocreau. young widow
8.F.46. Cass civ 2e, 14 October 1992, Schmitt v Laporte. mother taking care of injured child
8.F.47. Cass civ 2e, 3 October 1990, Compagnie General Accident v Bauthéas. management of husband's firm by his widow after his death (1)
8.F.48. Cass civ 2e, 2 November 1994, Compagnie General Accident v Bauthéas. management of husband's firm by his widow after his death (2)

@ 8.5.3. English Law (Additional Materials)

Introductory Note
8.E.49. Court of Appeal, Moeliker v A Reyrolle and Co. injured craftsman
8.E.50. House of Lords, Hunt v Severs. tortfeasor taking care of the plaintiff

8.6. Other Remedies

8.6.1. English Law

Introductory Note
8.E.51. House of Lords, Redland Bricks Ltd v Morris. land slip
8.E.52. Court of Appeal, Shelfer v City of London Electric Lighting Co. nuisance by electricity company

8.6.2. German Law

Introductory Note
8.G.53. BGH, 24 April 1970. illegally erected extensions
8.G.54. BGH, 26 February 1993. noisy ballet school

8.6.3. French Law

Introductory Note
8.F.55. Paris, 24 June 1980, Citroën v éditions Olivier Orban. car manufacturer's widow insulted
8.F.56. Cass civ 1re, 1 March 1965, Cliquet v Cousin. illegally erected garage

8.7. Comparative Overview

Classification of remedies
The purposes of redress for injury and the general principles of assessment of damages
The effect of the form of compensation and procedural rules on the implementation of the principle of full reparation
The implementation of the principle of full reparation in the case of loss of or damage to property
The implementation of the principle of full reparation in the case of personal injury and death
In conclusion